Should Women Lacrosse Players Wear Helmets?

February 21, 2011

Must See Lacrosse Videos

Increased public awareness of concussions and their effects—from the NFL to youth leagues—makes it easy to understand the argument for requiring helmets, even in a sport like women’s lacrosse. But after a heated debate at the annual National Organizing Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment last month, U.S. Lacrosse will continue its ban on hard helmets and face guards for women. The decision impacts more than 250,000 women playing nationwide.

Columbia women’s lacrosse freshman midfielder Camille Richardson agrees with the decision. She has no desire to wear a helmet, saying “it would just bring us closer to football and hockey.” Her teammate Kelly Buechel points out that she’d rather have a team “beat [her] because they’re more skilled, not because they’re more brutal.”

After professional hockey players began wearing helmets in the 1970s and '80s, the game became significantly more vicious. Helmet-to-helmet collisions in football seem to happen frequently at every level of play. Would girls' lacrosse—in which it is currently illegal at all levels to body check—become more dangerous if the players wore   helmets? Columbia senior attacker Olivia Mann notes that after protective eyewear was made mandatory at the beginning of the 2005 season, the game produced “general harder checking and rougher play.” The addition of helmets, and the tangible protection they represent, could dramatically change the nature of women's lacrosse, including the handling and manner of defense, with players putting their bodies and heads more at risk.

According to research by the Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Columbus Ohio, lacrosse has the third-highest concussion rate among women's scholastic sports (behind soccer and basketball). The concussion rate for females is only 15% lower than for males. Regardless of whether the “best protection is no protection at all,” one might consider the sports where the rules of the men's and women’s games are analogous—like soccer and basketball. It raises the question, Why are the rules of lacrosse different for men and women?

Source:  NY Times
Photo:  blog.patricksmithphotos.com

Maddy Lucier
- As an associate editor for STACK, Maddy creates lifestyle, social media, gear and nutrition content for our audience of athletes. She played volleyball and basketball...
Maddy Lucier
- As an associate editor for STACK, Maddy creates lifestyle, social media, gear and nutrition content for our audience of athletes. She played volleyball and basketball...
Must See
How to Perform the Euro Step With Iman Shumpert How to Perform the Euro Step With Iman Shumpert
Views: 85,104
NFL Wide Receiver Randall Cobb Outworks Everyone NFL Wide Receiver Randall Cobb Outworks Everyone
Views: 28,675,841
Dashon Goldson: Dashon Goldson: "You Just Gotta Have Heart"
Views: 5,064,359

Featured Videos

Real Workouts: Randall Cobb Real Workouts: Randall Cobb Views: 20,495
Greg Nixon's Full-Body Dumbbell Circuit Greg Nixon's Full-Body Dumbbell Circuit Views: 317,794
SEALFIT: Pushing the Limits of What Athletes Are Capable Of SEALFIT: Pushing the Limits of What Athletes Are Capable Of
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Derrick Rose Explains How He Stays Positive Derrick Rose Explains How He Stays Positive
Views: 6,081,054
Allyson Felix Explains How To Choose a Coach Allyson Felix Explains How To Choose a Coach
Views: 8,690,928
Dustin Pedroia on Training Dustin Pedroia on Training
Views: 10,919,945
Charging Ground Balls With Skip Schumaker Charging Ground Balls With Skip Schumaker
Views: 29,869
Yoga for Athletes: Crow Pose Yoga for Athletes: Crow Pose
Views: 3,539,411

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like
5 Exercises to Prevent ACL Tears

5 Exercises to Prevent ACL Tears

Fact: More than 70% of all Anterior Cruciate Ligament injuries are non-contact related. Another fact: Many of these injuries can be prevented with the...

How to Prevent Injuries With 3 Yoga Poses

How to Prevent Injuries With 3 Yoga Poses

Quarterbacks: 4 Tips to Keep Your Throwing Shoulder Healthy

Quarterbacks: 4 Tips to Keep Your Throwing Shoulder Healthy

Achilles Tendon Ruptures: Prevention and Recovery

Achilles Tendon Ruptures: Prevention and Recovery

6 Ways to Prevent Common Sports Injuries

6 Ways to Prevent Common Sports Injuries

Impressive Advances in ACL Rehab

Impressive Advances in ACL Rehab

Sports Hernias: What You Need to Know

Sports Hernias: What You Need to Know

STUDY: Imaginary Exercise Helps You Recover Faster From Injury

STUDY: Imaginary Exercise Helps You Recover Faster From Injury

Predicting the Impact of DeMarco Murray's Hand Injury

Predicting the Impact of DeMarco Murray's Hand Injury

3 Ways to Prevent the Most Common Hockey Injury

3 Ways to Prevent the Most Common Hockey Injury

8 of the Most Ridiculous Off-Field Athlete Injuries of All Time

8 of the Most Ridiculous Off-Field Athlete Injuries of All Time

Connective Tissue: The Key to Preventing ACL Injuries

Connective Tissue: The Key to Preventing ACL Injuries

Prevent ACL Injuries With This Hamstring-Focused Workout

Prevent ACL Injuries With This Hamstring-Focused Workout

10 Ways to Fix Back Pain

10 Ways to Fix Back Pain

Pectoral Tendon Ruptures and Injury Prevention

Pectoral Tendon Ruptures and Injury Prevention

The Future of Sports Injury Rehabilitation

The Future of Sports Injury Rehabilitation

What You Need to Know About Tiger Woods' Back Injury

What You Need to Know About Tiger Woods' Back Injury

How to Train With Running Blisters

How to Train With Running Blisters

Eliminate Elbow Pain with These 3 Methods

Eliminate Elbow Pain with These 3 Methods

Avoid Low-Back Pain With These 7 In-Season Exercises

Avoid Low-Back Pain With These 7 In-Season Exercises

Evan Gattis's Protection-Enhanced Catcher's Helmet

Evan Gattis's Protection-Enhanced Catcher's Helmet

How to Keep Your Feet Healthy On and Off the Field

How to Keep Your Feet Healthy On and Off the Field

The Secret Weapon Powering Stephen Curry's Resurgence

The Secret Weapon Powering Stephen Curry's Resurgence

Megan Rapinoes Secret to Staying Healthy

Megan Rapinoe

5 Things You Can Do to Prevent Muscle Injuries

5 Things You Can Do to Prevent Muscle Injuries

Coaches: Prevent Injuries With the Recovery Management Tool

Coaches: Prevent Injuries With the Recovery Management Tool

5 Bodyweight Exercises to Prevent Baseball Injuries

5 Bodyweight Exercises to Prevent Baseball Injuries

6 Simple Tips to Prevent Knee Injuries

6 Simple Tips to Prevent Knee Injuries

How to Treat Piriformis Syndrome

How to Treat Piriformis Syndrome

7 Ways to Fix Back Pain

7 Ways to Fix Back Pain

Why Strengthening This Muscle May Fix Knee Pain

Why Strengthening This Muscle May Fix Knee Pain

Outsmart Injury With These 4 Predictive Tests

Outsmart Injury With These 4 Predictive Tests

4 Strategies to Prevent Tommy John Surgery

4 Strategies to Prevent Tommy John Surgery

4 Sports Massage Techniques to Relieve Tight Muscles

4 Sports Massage Techniques to Relieve Tight Muscles

Bulletproof Your Body with 5 Easy Injury Prevention Exercises

Bulletproof Your Body with 5 Easy Injury Prevention Exercises

2 Ways to Fix Anterior Pelvic Tilt

2 Ways to Fix Anterior Pelvic Tilt

Basketball Players: Prevent Ankle Sprains With These 3 Exercises

Basketball Players: Prevent Ankle Sprains With These 3 Exercises

6 Steps for Recovering From a Season-Ending Injury

6 Steps for Recovering From a Season-Ending Injury

5 Tips to Intelligently Train Through Lower Back Pain

5 Tips to Intelligently Train Through Lower Back Pain

How to Prevent Baseball Injuries During the Off-Season

How to Prevent Baseball Injuries During the Off-Season

3 Steps to Prevent Soccer ACL Injuries

3 Steps to Prevent Soccer ACL Injuries

Tips for Working Out With a Hand or Arm Injury

Tips for Working Out With a Hand or Arm Injury

The 8 Most Dangerous Exercises for Your Shoulders

The 8 Most Dangerous Exercises for Your Shoulders

YardBarker