Three Machine Exercises Athletes Should Avoid

April 9, 2012

Must See Strength Training Videos

New training notions seem to spread extremely fast within the fitness industry. But "revolutionary" ideas circulating through crowds of workout warriors are often a double-edged sword. Research is constantly conflicting, and steadfast claims can be completely discredited weeks, months or years later.

Thus, when trendy claims about the next superfood, the best dietary supplement, the greatest cardio routine or the quickest way to build muscle start spreading like wildfire, problems can arise. The upside of fast circulating information is that when good tips do come along, they tend to get the recognition they deserve. However, the good gets muddled in with the bad, making it hard to know the best course of action.

As a strength and conditioning coach, one of my biggest concerns is exercise selection. Whether it's an athlete doing some extra, unguided work, or a position coach mimicking what he saw back in the '70s, or an administrator executing the latest YouTube workout move, I've observed many cringe-worthy routines. Much like the popular "Eat This, Not That" series, perhaps we need a bulletin board displaying "Build Muscle Like This, Not That" hung in every weight room.

Off the top of my head, I can reel off an extensive list of exercises to avoid, but let's keep this round simple. Here are three common lower-body exercises for which substituting a Squat could go a long way:

Smith Machine

The Smith Machine, while meant for Squatting, actually sets a lifter up for pain and injury, both short- and long-term. Due to its vertical sliding track, which allows for no deviation from the set pathway, the machine puts the body through an unnatural range of motion, forcing the lifter to go through a linear—not arched—path and placing undue stress on the knees, lower back and shoulders.

Smith Machine Squats

Leg Press

Don't get me wrong, there is a definite time and place for the Leg Press machine. It serves as one of the main progressions in a rehabilitation program for lower-body injury, and it can even facilitate good prehab work, since it promote some extra quad strengthening. However, using a machine removes many of the crucial byproducts that result from a free weight movement. One of the greatest benefits of a Squat movement—whether bodyweight, back, front or single-leg—is the stabilization and mobilization that it helps cultivate. The Leg Press does not engage any of the stabilization muscles of the core; and there is little or no recruitment of the hips, glutes and lower back. If your objective is to get in a little extra quad work after a good session of squatting, then press away. Just note that the Leg Press machine can force the spine into flex if the movement is not carefully executed.

Leg Press Machine

Leg Extension

Again, there can be a time and place for the Leg Extension machine. Like the Leg Press, it is appropriate for rehab, prehab and strengthening. However, when you look at the motion the legs perform (see picture below), you would be hard pressed to think of a time in real life when your legs actually execute this motion—and that's because it's a movement the lower body is not designed to do. If heavily loaded, the machine can place stress and strain on the tendons and ligaments surrounding the kneecaps. Plus, all the stabilization benefits are lost on a seated machine, not to mention the lack of glute and hamstring recruitment. Since weak glutes and hamstrings are key issues strength coaches often have to address with their athletes, the Leg Extension machine should be the at the bottom of the list of go-to movements.

Leg Extension Machine

Learn more about the Squat and different variations with our How-To Squat Series.

Photo:  bodybuilding.com

Alex Boyd currently serves as an assistant strength and conditioning coach at Middle Tennessee State University, where she works with the women’s volleyball, soccer and softball programs. She previously served as a graduate assistant strength and conditioning coach at Eastern Illinois University and as a sports performance intern at Stanford University. She earned her undergraduate degree in physiology from the University of Arizona in 2010, while simultaneously serving as a strength and conditioning intern. Boyd is CSCS, SCCC, RSCC and CPT-certified, and she has presented at the Illinois NSCA Conference.

Alex Boyd
- Alex Boyd currently serves as an assistant strength and conditioning coach at Middle Tennessee State University, where she works with the women’s volleyball, soccer and...
Alex Boyd
- Alex Boyd currently serves as an assistant strength and conditioning coach at Middle Tennessee State University, where she works with the women’s volleyball, soccer and...

Featured Videos

Adrian Gonzalez Rope Plank Adrian Gonzalez Rope Plank Views: 632,343
Ronda Rousey Shows Off Intense New Bag Drill Ronda Rousey Shows Off Intense New Bag Drill Views: 68,124
Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 5: Fundamentals Training Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 5: Fundamentals Training Views: 1,524,960
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill
Views: 6,866,164
Dustin Pedroia on Training Dustin Pedroia on Training
Views: 10,920,831
Peyton Manning Dumbbell Bench With 80+ Pounds Peyton Manning Dumbbell Bench With 80+ Pounds
Views: 43,057,815
Dwight Howard Stays in the Gym All Night Dwight Howard Stays in the Gym All Night
Views: 6,082,676
Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied
Views: 11,974,019

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like
5 Things to Remember When You Wing Your Workout

5 Things to Remember When You Wing Your Workout

2015 Summer Training Guide: Volleyball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Volleyball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Track

2015 Summer Training Guide: Track

Strength Isn’t Just How Much You Can Lift on a Barbell

Strength Isn't Just How Much You Can Lift on a Barbell

Olympian Carrie Tollefson's Core Workout

Olympian Carrie Tollefson's Core Workout

2015 Summer Training Guide: Baseball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Baseball

Mix Up Your Workout With Unique Partner Exercises

Mix Up Your Workout With Unique Partner Exercises

Fix 7 Common Problem Areas with Exercises From Todd Durkin

Fix 7 Common Problem Areas with Exercises From Todd Durkin

Build Elite Strength With This Training System

Build Elite Strength With This Training System

Improve Your Power With These Hardcore Methods

Improve Your Power With These Hardcore Methods

Are You Using the Right Weight for Every Exercise?

Are You Using the Right Weight for Every Exercise?

10-Minute Dynamic Warm-Up for Any Workout

10-Minute Dynamic Warm-Up for Any Workout

7 Trap Bar Exercises You Should Try

7 Trap Bar Exercises You Should Try

2015 Summer Training Guide: Lacrosse

2015 Summer Training Guide: Lacrosse

What Sport Coaches Need to Know About Strength and Conditioning

What Sport Coaches Need to Know About Strength and Conditioning

Bulletproof Shoulders: A Shoulder Training Guide

Bulletproof Shoulders: A Shoulder Training Guide

2015 Summer Training Guide: Football

2015 Summer Training Guide: Football

The Most American Workout Ever

The Most American Workout Ever

Building Brakes for More Speed

Building Brakes for More Speed

2015 Summer Training Guide: Basketball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Basketball

Troubleshooting the Lunge: How to Fix Your Form

Troubleshooting the Lunge: How to Fix Your Form

Marcus Mariota's Speed and Strength Workout

Marcus Mariota's Speed and Strength Workout

2015 Summer Training Guide: Soccer

2015 Summer Training Guide: Soccer

How to Build Strong Neck Muscles

How to Build Strong Neck Muscles

Build Lower-Body Power with This Squat Workout

Build Lower-Body Power with This Squat Workout

9 Ways to Improve Your Squat Technique

9 Ways to Improve Your Squat Technique

Battle Rope Workout That Will Get You Shredded

Battle Rope Workout That Will Get You Shredded

Use Single-Leg Strength to Enhance Soccer Performance

Use Single-Leg Strength to Enhance Soccer Performance

A Modern Twist to the Original Burpee

A Modern Twist to the Original Burpee

2015 Summer Training Guide: Wrestling

2015 Summer Training Guide: Wrestling

The 10-Minute Grip Strengthening Workout

The 10-Minute Grip Strengthening Workout

2015 Summer Training Guide: Softball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Softball

Why Single-Arm and Single-Leg Training is Better for Athletes

Why Single-Arm and Single-Leg Training is Better for Athletes

Why You Should Add Depth Jumps to Your Workouts

Why You Should Add Depth Jumps to Your Workouts

Go Against Traditional Workout Order for Bigger Gains

Go Against Traditional Workout Order for Bigger Gains

Why Reverse Lunges Are Better Than Forward Lunges

Why Reverse Lunges Are Better Than Forward Lunges

8 Ways to Use a Weight Vest in Your Workouts

8 Ways to Use a Weight Vest in Your Workouts

YardBarker