Will Eating Too Much Protein Harm Your Health? | STACK

Will Eating Too Much Protein Harm Your Health?

October 3, 2012 | Dr. Mike T. Nelson

Must See Nutrition Videos

Everyone looking to gain lean muscle and lose fat has probably heard that consuming protein is a key part of the process. (Learn more about post-game nutrition.) But can you eat too much protein? The simple answer is yes, but there is more to the story. Read on to find out how much protein is safe for athletes.

Common Misconceptions

The most common one is the concern about kidney function with a high-protein det. To understand this issue, you need to distinguish between "more work" and "damage." It's true that if you eat more protein, your kidneys have to do more work to break it down. However, this is not an entirely bad thing in healthy people, and it does not cause kidney damage.

Think of your kidneys as muscles. When you go to the gym and work out, your muscles get bigger and stronger by adapting to the stress you put on them. The kidneys are similar. If you look closely, you will see increased markers of more work being done, but no indications of damage. The kidneys work harder, but they soon adapt to the increased demand and go on their merry way without any complaints.

Protein and Kidney Damage Data

Dr. Lonnie Lowery has performed some great studies on this issue, since he got tired of hearing how higher protein intakes would cause your kidneys to explode out of your body and fly across the room (okay, maybe not). His most recent one was presented at the International Society of Sports Nutrition conference last year, which concluded: "A multi-year intake of ample protein among male Caucasian strength athletes does not affect common markers of renal (kidney) function." This was a multi-year study in strength athletes just like you. They were not looking at couch potatoes who ate more protein.

Are 400 Grams of Protein a Day Safe?

Of course, anything that can help you can also hurt you (including water). Thus, consumption of more than 1.5 grams of protein per pound of body weight is neither needed nor recommended.

When I teach nutrition, I give extra credit to anyone who can show me an actual peer-reviewed study of healthy people in which protein was considered bad for renal (kidney) health. After many classes, nobody has found anything, even though many nutrition textbooks will still tell you too much protein is not safe.

Summary

A higher intake of protein in healthy subjects has not been shown to be harmful to their kidneys. The kidneys may do work, but are able to adapt to the increased demand.

It's best to take around 1 gram of protein per pound and do not exceed 1.5 grams per pound. While there is no conclusive evidence that protein harms the body, anything taken in excess can have potentially damaging effects.

FROM AROUND THE WEB

Get the scoop on protein through STACK's Protein Guide.

References

Glassock RJ. "Is the presence of microalbuminuria a relevant marker of kidney disease?" Curr Hypertens Rep. 2010 Oct;12(5):364-8.

Lonnie M Lowery, Allison Daugherty, Brian Miller, Sarah Dye and Loren Liming. "The effect of habitually large protein intake on renal function of strength athletes: an update." Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2011, 8(Suppl 1):P33
doi:10.1186/1550-2783-8-S1-P33

Lorena Devia, Josh Huffman, James Mihevic, Anna Huszti and Lonnie Lowery. "Dietary protein, resistance training and health: a call for evidence." Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2008, 5(Suppl 1):P23 doi:10.1186/1550-2783-5-S1-P23

Photo: commons.wikimedia.com

Topics: PROTEIN
Mike T. Nelson
- Mike T. Nelson has spent nearly two decades learning how the human body works, with a focus on conditioning to burn fat, improve flexibility, gain...
Mike T. Nelson
- Mike T. Nelson has spent nearly two decades learning how the human body works, with a focus on conditioning to burn fat, improve flexibility, gain...
More Cool Stuff You'll Like

A Guide to Muscle-Building Supplements

The Best Supplements for Building Muscle

Get the Most Out of Your Post-Workout Protein

Will Eating Too Much Protein Harm Your Health?

Safe and Effective Supplements for Athletes

5 High-Protein Breakfasts for Athletes

ProBar: What All Whole Food Bars Should Taste Like

EAS Launches New Recovery Protein Powder

Workout Supplements: Do You Really Need Them?

Protein-Packed Smoothies Without Protein Powder

Do You Need Protein Immediately After Your Workout?

5 Protein-Packed Recovery Shakes

Hungry? Try the DIY Protein Bar

4 Amazing Benefits of Protein

Finding the Right Protein Balance

Protein Powder Potato Chips? ProTings, Reviewed

6 Supplements That Power Quality Workouts

7 Delicious Muscle-Building Smoothie Recipes

Complete Your Nutrition with Incomplete Proteins

High-Protein Breakfast Ideas for Vegetarians

4 Post-Workout Shakes for Recovery and Building Muscle

Design the Perfect Muscle-Building Post-Workout Meal

Soy vs. Whey Protein

We Tried Cricket Protein Bars. Should You?

The Truth About Muscle-Enhancing Supplements

Surviving Football Hell Week: A Nutrition Guide

High Protein Diets Won't Fix Everything

How to Select a Healthy Protein Bar

8 High-Protein Breakfast Ideas

Are You Eating Too Much Protein?

How Protein Makes Muscles Bigger

Consuming Protein to Build Muscle

20 Delicious Ways to Add Protein to Your Diet

Key Nutrients for Athletes

5 High Protein Vegetarian Snacks

How Much Protein Do You Need?

Answering Common Questions From Female Athletes

True Nutrition: Possibly The Best Protein Supplement

Eat Healthy to Build Muscle

Why Protein Alone Doesn't Build Muscle