Was Mark Sanchez Ever a Good NFL Quarterback?

January 3, 2013

Must See Football Videos

On Dec. 17, Mark Sanchez bent down to scoop up a low snap from his center, Nick Mangold, and down with him went the New York Jets' season. As the ball lay motionless on the ground, running back Bilal Powell inadvertently kicked it out of Sanchez’s reach and into the waiting hands of a Titans defensive lineman. Sanchez looked on in bewilderment before trudging back to the sideline, his shoulders hunched over like he knew his starting job was gone.

The Jets' 6-10 season was a constant lowlight reel that deserves a permanent spot on ESPN’s "Not Top Ten." Sanchez especially struggled late in the season, with plays like the infamous “butt fumble,” forever attached to his tenure wearing green and white. This year's Sanchez-led team was a far cry from the 2009-2010 back-to-back AFC Championsip squads. After an abysmal season filled with trade rumors, we have to ask: was Mark Sanchez really ever a good NFL quarterback?

The Facts

As a rookie QB in 2009, Sanchez nabbed the Jets starting quarterback job out of training camp and proceeded to take his team to the AFC Championship. He did the same in 2010. At the time, it seemed like Sanchez was the guy who would eventually take the Jets to the promised land. But a plunge into the numbers tells a much different story.

The 2009, the Jets sent five players to the Pro Bowl. The 2010 squad sent three more. In 2009, the Jets ranked first overall in total defense, coming in third the following year. Offensively? The Jets ranked 2oth in total offense in 2009, jumping up to 11th the next season. But if you separate out the rushing attack, which was a massive part of the Jets offense, the numbers for Mark Sanchez are alarming. The Jets ranked 31st (second to last) in passing in 2009, and 22nd the next year. The Jets' success appears to have been based on their running game and stellar defense, rather than on Sanchez's arm.

The Stats

Let’s look at Sanchez's individual numbers. His completion percentage, a stat that usually reflects a quarterback’s accuracy, has hovered around 55 percent during his four years in the league, astonishingly bad for a starting quarterback. For comparison’s sake, another benched starter, Alex Smith, was completing 70 percent of his passes this year, while a rookie, Russell Wilson, hit his target 63 percent of the time. A decent NFL quarterback should have a completion percentage in the 60s.

Another number to look at is Total Quarterback Rating (Total QBR), an advanced metric that takes into account underthrows, overthrows, defensive strength, clutch situations and other factors to determine the true worth of a QB. On a scale of 0 to 100, an average quarterback has a rating of 50. Sanchez came in 26th with a rating of 31.6 in 2009, and 18th with a rating of 48 in 2010. His rank this season? A horrendous 36th, with a Total QBR rating of 25.

It’s hard to look past the stats. Even protected by an offensive line that boasted multiple Pro Bowlers, and surrounded by talented guys like Santonio Holmes, Plexico Burress, Braylon Edwards, Thomas Jones and LaDanian Tomlinson, Sanchez has struggled to be just mediocre. This mediocrity is a big reason why Sanchez no longer has a grasp on the starting quarterback job in New York, and why his time in the Big Apple (and as an NFL starting QB) may be just about up.

Photo via jetsgab.com

Jordan Zirm
- Jordan Zirm is an Associate Content Director for STACK. After earning his BS in Journalism from the University of Missouri, he spent time writing for...
Jordan Zirm
- Jordan Zirm is an Associate Content Director for STACK. After earning his BS in Journalism from the University of Missouri, he spent time writing for...
Must See
Michael Jordan: Mind of a Champion
Views: 546,272
Antonio Brown Juggles 3 Footballs
Views: 1,203,239
Dashon Goldson: "You Just Gotta Have Heart"
Views: 4,811,110

Featured Videos

A Day in the Life of NBA D-League Star Seth Curry Views: 66,647
Kevin Love's Cone Hop Basketball Shooting Drill Views: 5,931
Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 2: Laying the Groundwork Views: 124,090
Load More


STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers


Latest issues of STACK Magazine


Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice


Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes


Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Perfect Dwyane Wade's Signature Euro Step
Views: 1,308,654
What Ryan Hall Eats for Breakfast
Views: 795,206
STACK Fitness Weekly: How To Do a Muscle-Up
Views: 778,612
Greg Nixon's Hill Training Program
Views: 705,718
Roy Hibbert 540 lbs Deadlift
Views: 1,559,831

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like

NHL All-Stars Drop In For a Game of Sledge Hockey

Social Media Roundup: Don't Call J.J. Watt 'Bae'

Meet Ricky Johnson, Red Bull Frozen Rush Champion

The 7 Most Epic Smack Talk Fails in Sports History

Social Media Roundup: Adam Jones Channels His Inner Prince Akeem

The Most Amazing Vines From the First Round of the NBA Playoffs

Who the Heck Is Grayson Allen?

WATCH: J.J. Watt's Insane 61-Inch Box Jump

Beating the Elements: The 6 Worst Weather Games of All Time

WATCH: Never-Before-Seen J.J. Watt High School Highlight Reel

Quick Review: Columbia Sportswear Turbodown Jacket

WATCH: Kyrie Irving Runs the Floor in High School

WATCH: Steph Curry Drains 77 Straight 3-Pointers in Practice

Is the Armpocket Truly 'The Ultimate' Armband? Find Out Here.

8 Pro Athletes Who Are Clearly Showing Off During Workouts

WATCH: James Harden Dominates in High School

6 Ways Sport Parents Are Doing It Wrong

Cleveland Browns Release New Uniforms

7 Insanely Drastic MLB Body Transformations

WATCH: Tom Brady Bats Lefty, Practices Swing with Pedro Martinez

The Must-See Vines of the NCAA Tournament's Opening Rounds

5 Superstars Who Spent Time on Awful Teams

I Ran the 40-Yard Dash at the NFL Combine and Sucked at It

Mythcrusher: Does a Fast 40-Yard Dash Predict NFL Success?

My 3-Mile Run With Kendrick Lamar

Social Media Roundup: Jameis Winston on a Jetpack

Stephen Curry's Long-Range Game: Does Anyone Come Close?

18 Strangest and Most Impressive Fitness Records