The 5 Biggest Misses at the NFL Combine

March 1, 2013

Must See Football Videos

Analysts, scouts, and coaches are only human, and with human judgement comes human error. Opinions abound during the NFL Combine, as prospects run the 40-Yard Dash, Bench Press, jump and perform other physical tests in front of representatives from all 32 NFL teams. But how much stock should you put in a player's performance? Does a blazing 40 time translate to the field? Does benching 225 pounds over 20 times equal football strength? These questions have been asked for years, and for good reason. From players who had a poor combine and went on to dominate in the NFL to guys who proved to be nothing more than workout warriors, here are the five biggest misses teams and analysts have made at the NFL Combine.

1. Joe Haden Knocked for Being Slow

Haden

Back in 2010, Florida Gators cornerback Joe Haden was gearing up for the NFL Combine and looking like a top ten pick in the upcoming Draft. But after he ran a slightly disappointing 4.57 in his 40-Yard Dash, analysts from the NFL Network started second guessing just how good Haden might be. Analyst Bucky Brooks said, ”it’s going to be hard for some scouts to get that 4.57 out of their mind when they think about [Haden] being an elite player. It’s rare for a team to take a guy with that kind of speed as a top 15 or top 10 pick.”

Well, Haden ended up going number seven overall to the Cleveland Browns, but the criticism didn’t stop. Michael Lombardi, writing for NFL.com, stated that ”According to coaches around the league, Browns first-round pick Joe Haden has not been very impressive in camps and might not have enough speed to play corner.”

All Haden did was record 64 tackles and six interceptions his rookie year. Going into his fourth year in the league, Mr. Haden is doing just fine for himself.

2. Jonathan Sullivan Lasts 3 Seasons

Sully

Sullivan is a classic case of a player’s draft stock shooting up because of a stellar workout. After running a 5.03 40-Yard Dash (impressive for a guy who weighed over 300 pounds) and performing well in many other areas of the 2003 Combine, Sullivan caught the attention of the New Orleans Saints, who decided to take him with the sixth overall pick in the draft. After a handful of mediocre seasons and an arrest for possession of marijuana, Sullivan was out of the league in three years. Ouch.

3. Vernon Gholston Fools the Jets

Vernon Gholston

After plowing through quarterbacks as a defensive lineman for Ohio State, Gholston put his freakish athletic talents on display during the 2008 NFL Combine. He ran an insanely fast 4.56 40 and pumped out 37 reps during the 225- pound Bench Press, tying a Combine record. Scouts raved about his ability, and NFL.com called him a ”remarkable talent.” Telling the difference between a guy who can perform at a high level in the weight room and one who can translate those skills onto the field can be tricky, but hey, that’s what NFL scouts get paid to do, and the New York Jets swung and missed. After getting chosen with the sixth overall pick in the 2008 NFL Draft, Gholston played three underwhelming seasons before being released in 2010. He hasn’t seen the field since.

4. Matt Jones Wows Peter King

Matt Jones

A former quarterback at the University of Arkansas, the 6’6” Matt Jones turned heads at the 2005 Combine when he ran a 4.37 40-Yard Dash and leaped more than 40 inches in the vertical. No one knew where he would play (quarterback, wide receiver, tight end?), but he led respected Sports Illustrated writer Peter King to remark that ”we haven’t seen this kind of player come around in a long time.”

Turns out we had. The Jacksonville Jaguars took Jones in the first round and tried him out at wide receiver, an experiment that went all kinds of wrong. Jones strung together a few mediocre seasons before his bout with substance abuse prompted the Jags to release him. He was then cut by the Cincinnati Bengals before training camp in 2010.

5. Vontaze Burfict's Draft Stock Plummets

Bontaze Burfict

Vontaze Burfict was a stud linebacker during his college career at Arizona State, but the projected first-round pick came into the 2012 NFL Combine with some baggage after being pegged as a hothead. He did himself no favors at the Combine, running an uber-slow 5.09 40-Yard Dash and reportedly blaming his coaches for his up and down junior season in team interviews.

Burfict went completely undrafted after the Combine, a shock for a guy who was once considered one of the top three linebackers in the 2012 draft. Burfict signed on with the Cincinnati Bengals, where he would start 14 games and lead the team in tackles with 127. He’s also been incident-free during his time in the NFL. Sometimes you’ve got to dig a little deeper on a guy, and 31 teams whiffed on Burfict.

Photos via ESPN, NFL.com, businessinsider.com, Bleacher Report, jacksonville.com, rumorsandrants.com

Jordan Zirm
- Jordan Zirm is an Associate Content Director for STACK. After earning his BS in Journalism from the University of Missouri, he spent time writing for...
Jordan Zirm
- Jordan Zirm is an Associate Content Director for STACK. After earning his BS in Journalism from the University of Missouri, he spent time writing for...
Must See
NFL Wide Receiver Randall Cobb Outworks Everyone
Views: 28,507,498
Abby Wambach Will Do Whatever It Takes
Views: 4,541,559
How to Perform the Euro Step With Iman Shumpert
Views: 85,034

Featured Videos

Abby Wambach's Med Ball Core Workout Views: 187,099
Kevin Love's Cone Hop Basketball Shooting Drill Views: 12,178
Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 5: Fundamentals Training Views: 220,234
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Charging Ground Balls With Skip Schumaker
Views: 29,842
Yoga for Athletes: Crow Pose
Views: 3,539,378
Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill
Views: 6,865,919
Evan Longoria's Hitting Drills
Views: 9,798,784
Johny Hendricks Workout Overview
Views: 822,554

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like

5 Superstars Who Spent Time on Awful Teams

Is the Armpocket Truly 'The Ultimate' Armband? Find Out Here.

7 Insanely Drastic MLB Body Transformations

WATCH: J.J. Watt's Insane 61-Inch Box Jump

Who the Heck Is Grayson Allen?

Cleveland Browns Release New Uniforms

Beating the Elements: The 6 Worst Weather Games of All Time

My 3-Mile Run With Kendrick Lamar

NHL All-Stars Drop In For a Game of Sledge Hockey

The Most Amazing Vines From the First Round of the NBA Playoffs

6 Ways Sport Parents Are Doing It Wrong

Stephen Curry's Long-Range Game: Does Anyone Come Close?

Quick Review: Columbia Sportswear Turbodown Jacket

Mythcrusher: Does a Fast 40-Yard Dash Predict NFL Success?

The 7 Most Epic Smack Talk Fails in Sports History

WATCH: James Harden Dominates in High School

Social Media Roundup: Don't Call J.J. Watt 'Bae'

WATCH: Never-Before-Seen J.J. Watt High School Highlight Reel

Meet Ricky Johnson, Red Bull Frozen Rush Champion

The Must-See Vines of the NCAA Tournament's Opening Rounds

WATCH: Kyrie Irving Runs the Floor in High School

WATCH: Steph Curry Drains 77 Straight 3-Pointers in Practice

Social Media Roundup: Jameis Winston on a Jetpack

WATCH: Tom Brady Bats Lefty, Practices Swing with Pedro Martinez

Social Media Roundup: Adam Jones Channels His Inner Prince Akeem

I Ran the 40-Yard Dash at the NFL Combine and Sucked at It

8 Pro Athletes Who Are Clearly Showing Off During Workouts

18 Strangest and Most Impressive Fitness Records