Nutrition experts critical of juicing trend | STACK Fitness
X

Become a Better Athlete. Sign Up for our FREE Newsletter.

The Skinny on Juicing

July 31, 2013 | Christie Carlson

Must See Nutrition Videos

Juicing is a popular trend in dieting these days. But with all of its promises as a health solution, is it really all it's cracked up to be? Some registered dietitians and doctors seem to think not.

Advocates of juicing claim that it cleanses the body of harmful toxins, but Joan Salge Blake, a registered dietitian and clinical associate professor at Boston University, points out that we already have an amazing detoxifier in our bodies—our livers.

Going out of your way to rid your body of toxins by limiting your food intake is redundant. A better way to cleanse your body is to increase your water intake and eat more fruits and vegetables in lieu of processed and junk foods, says Stella Volpe, a professor and chair of the department of Nutrition Sciences at Drexel University.[1]

If you truly want to rid yourself of gunk building up in your body, take a hard look at what you're eating on a daily basis. Eat fresh, whole foods and drink lots of water, and you will feel more energized and healthier in no time.

Another issue with juicing is the healthy fiber you lose out on. Fruits and vegetables contain fiber, which help with satiety, the feeling of being full. If you remove the fiber by juicing your fruits and veggies, you probably won't feel full and you'll be more likely to want to eat something later, says registered dietitian Rachel Griehs.[2]

Fruits and some vegetables also contain large amounts of sugar. It's not refined, like white sugar, but it's sugar nonetheless. In my experience as a personal trainer and a strength and conditioning coach, clients on juice fasts are easily fatigued and rather grouchy. Much of their fatigue and irritability is the result of a lack of necessary calories, while a part of it is due to blood insulin spikes and subsequent drops they experience due to subsisting mainly on fructose (the sugar found in fruit).

One last thing to worry about with juicing is the freshness of the juice. Juice that has been sitting around for too long can be an excellent place for bacteria to grow, and it can make you sick. Mayo Clinic nutritionist Jennifer K. Nelson suggests making only as much as you can consume in one sitting, and if you buy your juice at the store, choosing a pasteurized brand.[3]

Many nutrition experts agree that replacing all or most of your daily nutrition with juice is a recipe for disaster. It can make you tired and irritable, and although you may lose a few pounds, you're likely to gain them back as soon as you begin eating whole foods again.

There is one upside to juicing. If you don't enjoy eating fruits or veggies, many of the experts I checked out agree that consuming them in juice form is better than not eating them at all.

[1] Chan, A. (2011, March 23). 5 experts answer: Is there such thing as a healthy juice cleanse?. Retrieved from http://www.livescience.com/35561-5-experts-answer-juice-cleanse.html

[2] Roncace, K. (2013, May 2). N.J. nutritionists weigh in on the pros and cons of juicing. Retrieved from http://www.nj.com/indulge/index.ssf/2013/05/area_nutritionists_weigh_in_on.html

[3] Nelson, J. K. (n.d.). Is juicing healthier than eating whole fruits or vegetables?. Retrieved from http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/juicing/AN02107

Read more:

Christie Carlson
- Christie Carlson is a certified strength and conditioning specialist (CSCS) and a personal trainer. She earned her Master of Science degree in Exercise and Sports...
Christie Carlson
- Christie Carlson is a certified strength and conditioning specialist (CSCS) and a personal trainer. She earned her Master of Science degree in Exercise and Sports...
More Cool Stuff You'll Like

Eat Like a Champion, Part 1: How to Build Muscle in the Kitchen

Welcome to the STACK Eat Like a Champion article series, where we'll talk to nutrition experts about how to eat to beat the competition and how to build...

Macronutrients, Part I: Carbohydrates

The Nutrition That Powers Joe Thomas's Iron-Man Streak

Avoid Pigging Out: How to Conquer Food Cravings

Low Workout Stamina? Your Diet May Be the Culprit

Coconut Sugar: What Is It, and Is It Good for You?

Game-Day Nutrition for Soccer Players

Building a Healthy Pizza: Tips and Recipes

How to Turn Nutrition Goals Into Actions

Simple Nutrition Tips for Faster Workout Gains

The Food Rules for Building Muscle

6 Fruits and Veggies You Aren't Eating But Should Be

Why Can't I Stop Gaining Weight?

Eat Like a Champion, Part 2: How to Lose Fat Safely

Russell Wilson Wants You to 'Eat the Ball'

8 Recovery Foods Recommended by Sport Dietitians

A Healthier Milk, Brought to You By Coca-Cola. Wait, What?

3 Nutrition Hacks to Improve Your Sports Performance

How Fatty Is Your Thanksgiving?

What You Need to Know about Fats

Types of Yogurt: What's New and What's Best for Athletes

The 5 Foods That Will Rule 2015

7 Pro Athletes Who Succeed Despite Having Horrible Diets

6 Ways to Power Up Your Oatmeal

Do You Need Protein Immediately After Your Workout?

Post-Holiday Chocolate Health Benefits

Why Chicken Soup Strengthens Your Immune System

Study Ranks Paleo As Second-Worst Diet

Cheerios With Quinoa: Coming Soon to a Grocery Store Near You

How and Why to Eat Mindfully

How to Build a Meal Plan to Suit Your Body Type

The 7 Best Nuts for Your Health and Performance

What You Need to Know About Protein

3 Tips to Eat Healthy on a Budget

Pre-Game Nutrition: What to Eat Before You Compete

4 Common Nutrition Questions Answered

We Tried Cricket Protein Bars. Should You?

Bone Broth Breakdown: Should You Eat This 'Super' Soup'?

Is All Sugar Bad for You?