Carb Backloading: Why Breakfast Is Not the Most Important Meal of the Day

March 13, 2013 | Mitch Calvert

Must See Nutrition Videos

Breakfast, "the most important meal of the day." Nowadays this could be considered the most essential rule in nutrition. If you want to have energy to fuel your day and your workout, better get up and eat your oatmeal. (We've said it: Athletes Eat Oatmeal for Breakfast.)

Fuel with carbohydrates early in the morning and gradually reduce your intake throughout the day, adding quality fats instead. Fitness industry experts have been telling us this for years. But is it really the best plan for optimal performance? It certainly doesn't fit the biological clock our ancestors abided by.

Popular diet trends like John Keifer's "Carb Backloading" have challenged the conventional wisdom with documented results. (Read more on carb backloading.) Keifer says, "Limiting carbs in the first half of the day forces your metabolism to rely on fat for its energy needs. When you limit your intake of food during this time, your body releases body fat for energy."

It's not just about diet fads. A 2010 study reported in the International Journal of Obesity recommends a complete reversal of today's "carbs for breakfast" mindset. The study, entitled "Time-of-Day-Dependent Dietary Fat Consumption Influences Multiple Cardiometabolic Syndrome Parameters in Mice" [1], suggests that consuming a meal higher in fat early in the day helps the body respond more appropriately to carbohydrate later in the day, whereas a high carbohydrate morning meal fixes metabolism towards carbohydrate utilization, impairing the body's ability to adjust metabolism toward fat utilization.

The take home message: avoid insulin-spiking foods (carbs) in the early part of the day, especially if you work a sedentary desk job. Fill up on carbs at night or after exercise, when your body is primed to absorb them properly in muscle cells. A sample menu would include early meals of lean meats, eggs, fibrous veggies and low glycemic carbs like berries, and pasta for dinner. Logically it makes sense. Eating carbs increases the production of serotonin, which makes you sleepy, so the best time to eat them would be a few hours before bedtime.

A counter-argument states that if you work out early in the morning, you need carbs for fuel. But research suggests a carbohydrate load the night before should be sufficient to keep you energized through a weightlifting workout. A 2013 study, "Nutrient timing revisited: is there a post-exercise anabolic window?" by researchers Alan Aragon and Brad Schoenfeld [2], recommends consuming 0.4-0.5 g/kg of protein per kg of lean body mass both pre- and post-exercise to negate any potential performance shortfall. That said, they note that endurance athletes need to take in carbohydrate during and after exercise, in contrast to athletes pursuing strictly strength or hypertrophy goals. Essentially, if your morning exercise is a prolonged endurance activity (say a two-hour hockey practice bright and early), then carbohydrate intake prior, during and after is appropriate for optimal performance.

Whether you adopt the Keifer's method or modify it to suit your athletic needs, don't be afraid to try a new approach. You may find your reward from ditching the oats is improved performance. And what athlete doesn't want that?

References

[1] Bray et al., "Time-of-Day-Dependent Dietary Fat Consumption Influences Multiple Cardiometabolic Syndrome Parameters in Mice." International Journal of Obesity (London). 2010 November; 34(11): 1589-1598.

[2] Aragon, A. & Schoenfeld, B., "Nutrient timing revisited: is there a post-exercise anabolic window?" Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 2013 January, http://www.jissn.com/content/10/1/5

Mitch Calvert
- Mitch Calvert, born and raised in Canada, chose a life of health and fitness eight years ago, transforming himself from a severely overweight teenager to...
Mitch Calvert
- Mitch Calvert, born and raised in Canada, chose a life of health and fitness eight years ago, transforming himself from a severely overweight teenager to...

Featured Videos

Path to the Pros 2015: Devin Smith Path to the Pros 2015: Devin Smith Views: 179,065
Path to the Pros 2015: Shaq Thompson Path to the Pros 2015: Shaq Thompson Views: 75,992
Blake Griffin Interview and Cover Shoot Blake Griffin Interview and Cover Shoot Views: 588,674
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Peyton Manning Dumbbell Bench With 80+ Pounds Peyton Manning Dumbbell Bench With 80+ Pounds
Views: 43,252,646
Ohio State Football Open Field Plyo Drill Ohio State Football Open Field Plyo Drill
Views: 9,501,192
Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill
Views: 6,866,172
Dustin Pedroia on Training Dustin Pedroia on Training
Views: 10,920,872
Dwight Howard Stays in the Gym All Night Dwight Howard Stays in the Gym All Night
Views: 6,117,437

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like
Cookout Commandments: What to Eat (and Avoid) at Your Summer BBQ

Cookout Commandments: What to Eat (and Avoid) at Your Summer BBQ

Small Change, Big Difference: 5 Foods You Should Buy Organic

Small Change, Big Difference: 5 Foods You Should Buy Organic

Brown Rice vs. White Rice: Does It Really Matter?

Brown Rice vs. White Rice: Does It Really Matter?

5 Delicious Ways to Make Junk Food Less Junky

5 Delicious Ways to Make Junk Food Less Junky

How to Eat Healthy at a Dingy Sports Bar

How to Eat Healthy at a Dingy Sports Bar

5 'Healthy' Side Dishes That Are Worse Than French Fries

5 'Healthy' Side Dishes That Are Worse Than French Fries

Why You Should Say No to Diet Foods

Why You Should Say No to Diet Foods

Registered Dietitians Reveal Their Favorite Ways to Eat Fruit

Registered Dietitians Reveal Their Favorite Ways to Eat Fruit

Where the Paleo Diet Falls Short

Where the Paleo Diet Falls Short

How Marc Gasol Got Better by Overhauling His Diet

How Marc Gasol Got Better by Overhauling His Diet

Salad Showdown: Which Greens Are the Healthiest?

Salad Showdown: Which Greens Are the Healthiest?

10 Athlete-Approved High-Protein Cereals

10 Athlete-Approved High-Protein Cereals

Terrible Toppings: The 5 Worst Things We Put on Food

Terrible Toppings: The 5 Worst Things We Put on Food

9 Athlete-Approved Peanut Butter Sandwiches

9 Athlete-Approved Peanut Butter Sandwiches

Binge Eating Disorder and Athletes

Binge Eating Disorder and Athletes

The Cheat Meal Day: Why It's Not So Smart

The Cheat Meal Day: Why It's Not So Smart

You Should Eat the Peel of These 12 Fruits and Vegetables

You Should Eat the Peel of These 12 Fruits and Vegetables

The Grain Guide: How and Why to Use 8 Healthy Whole Grains

The Grain Guide: How and Why to Use 8 Healthy Whole Grains

What to Eat If You Hate Bananas

What to Eat If You Hate Bananas

12 Foods Every Athlete Should Eat

12 Foods Every Athlete Should Eat

9 Foods to Eat When You Want to Lose Fat

9 Foods to Eat When You Want to Lose Fat

Vegetarian Athlete Tips: Olympic Swimmer Kate Ziegler

Vegetarian Athlete Tips: Olympic Swimmer Kate Ziegler

11 Food Services That Deliver Ready-Made Nutritious Meals

11 Food Services That Deliver Ready-Made Nutritious Meals

Are You Eating Too Much Protein?

Are You Eating Too Much Protein?

6 Healthy Foods You're Overeating

6 Healthy Foods You're Overeating

How Friends and Family Affect Your Food Choices

How Friends and Family Affect Your Food Choices

5 Protein-Packed Recovery Shakes

5 Protein-Packed Recovery Shakes

The Best Foods for Digestive Health

The Best Foods for Digestive Health

A Sneaky Food Additive Athletes Should Avoid

A Sneaky Food Additive Athletes Should Avoid

5 Healthy Foods That Got a Bad Rap

5 Healthy Foods That Got a Bad Rap

3 Fruits and 3 Vegetables Athletes Must Eat

3 Fruits and 3 Vegetables Athletes Must Eat

5 Simple Food Swaps That Make Eating Out Healthier

5 Simple Food Swaps That Make Eating Out Healthier

4 'Bad Foods' That Might be Good for You

4 'Bad Foods' That Might be Good for You

Healthy (and Unhealthy) BBQ Ideas For Athletes

Healthy (and Unhealthy) BBQ Ideas For Athletes

Fuel Up Fast With 4 Smoothies From the New York Giants

Fuel Up Fast With 4 Smoothies From the New York Giants

Load Up on These Foods at Your Backyard Barbecue

Load Up on These Foods at Your Backyard Barbecue

Healthy Eating at Restaurants: Decoding a Diner Menu

Healthy Eating at Restaurants: Decoding a Diner Menu

STUDY: Eat More Fruits and Veggies, Live (Almost) Forever

STUDY: Eat More Fruits and Veggies, Live (Almost) Forever

5 'Good Foods' That Might Be Bad for You

5 'Good Foods' That Might Be Bad for You

Healthy Makeovers for 3 Classic Meals

Healthy Makeovers for 3 Classic Meals

5 Foods That Are Stunningly High in Sodium

5 Foods That Are Stunningly High in Sodium

The Boston Cannons' ‘Keep It Real’ Eating Plan

The Boston Cannons' 'Keep It Real' Eating Plan

6 Eating Mistakes That Undo Your Workouts

6 Eating Mistakes That Undo Your Workouts

The Healthiest (And Unhealthiest) Ways to Eat Chicken

The Healthiest (And Unhealthiest) Ways to Eat Chicken

5 Ways Junk Food Can Mess With Your Head

5 Ways Junk Food Can Mess With Your Head

7 Foods That Are Ruining Your Workouts

7 Foods That Are Ruining Your Workouts

How Undereating Can Make You Gain Weight

How Undereating Can Make You Gain Weight

YardBarker