Is MMA Training Appropriate For Other Sports?

November 9, 2010

Must See MMA Videos

I’m a huge mixed martial arts fan and have been since I watched the very first Ultimate Fighting Championship. (Coincidentally, current MMA fighters Matt and Nick Serra were at my apartment watching it as well. At the time, none of us had any idea how big the sport would become or how fast it would grow.)

Over the years, I have trained extensively in boxing and Muay Thai. I’ve also studied Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, under Vitor “Shaolin” Ribeiro. I don’t claim to be a fighting wizard, but as an athlete and strength coach, I have a solid understanding of striking and ground fighting. In addition to my own experience, I’m currently training several successful MMA fighters, so I have the benefit of direct feedback on aspects of their training that work when competing at the highest level.

The increased popularity of MMA has sparked a trend for other pro athletes, especially football players, to use MMA training to get in shape for their sport. But before we go any further, let me state what I do not consider MMA training. Strongman work—such as odd object lifting, sled pushing/pulling and metabolic resistance circuits—is not MMA training (although I do use it in training my fighters). Similarly, striking and working with focus mitts for extra conditioning (to supplement normal off-season strength work) are not MMA training. I define MMA training as actual sparring while employing methods such as submission grappling, punching, kicking, kneeing, and elbowing.

Now that we know what it is and is not, here are three reasons why I’m not in favor of pro athletes using MMA training as an off-season training tool.

On the surface, MMA training seems like an interesting idea, especially for athletes who participate in contact sports like football or hockey. MMA guys are tough as nails. They are also among the best-conditioned athletes on the planet. That said, we need to explore the issue of risk vs. reward.

For an elite MMA fighter, over the course of his career—even knowing when to tap out if caught in an armbar, a kneebar or a neck crank—the chances of sustaining a significant injury during training are high. For a beginner, who doesn’t know when he’s in serious trouble, or whose ego won’t let him submit to a smaller opponent, it’s a recipe for disaster—especially if he’s a multi-million dollar athlete. When you consider that a pro athlete’s job is to be ready to compete when the season starts, it’s not a smart idea to train with such a high-risk method.

Second, consider the energy system demands on an MMA fighter. A typical MMA fight consists of three five-minute rounds with a one-minute rest between rounds. Championship bouts go for five five-minute rounds. It’s clear that energy system demands for MMA fighting are significantly higher than most team sports. Basically, an MMA fighter competes at a 5:1 work-to-recovery ratio. To fulfill this demand, he needs not only relative strength and power but also large aerobic capacity. In football, the average play lasts between five and 10 seconds, with a 40-second recovery—for a work-to-recovery ratio of between 1:4 and 1:8. For hockey, the average shift is somewhere between 45 and 50 seconds, with most teams rolling three to four lines, which works out to a 1:2 or 1:3 work-to-recovery ratio. Obviously, the energy demands between an MMA fighter and a football or hockey player are radically different.

Finally, all athletes need to understand and use the concept of specificity in training—i.e., training methods that directly transfer to the demands of the sport. Most strength coaches would agree that an off-season strength and conditioning program should progress an athlete from general physical preparation, through specific physical preparation, to sport-specific training. In general, during the early off-season, most athletes would benefit by focusing on correcting muscular imbalances that may have developed during the season. Therefore, mobility work and prehab exercises should take priority.

Certainly off-season training programs should take into account the demands of an athlete’s position; but in general, the emphasis should shift to improving maximum strength, functional hypertrophy and power development. After the first few weeks, basic movement drills aimed at improving linear and multi-directional capabilities should be added.

During the latter stages of the off-season, the focus of strength training should be on explosive strength, speed and endurance—depending on the requirements of the athlete’s sport or position. Energy system training should also relate to the metabolic demands of the sport. For example, late stage sport-specific training for a football player should include sprinting, cutting, shuffling, backpedaling and jumping.

MMA training develops none of these skills. Why use a training program if it doesn’t help you in your sport?

The reasons I’ve laid out—risk vs. reward, different energy system demands and the importance of specificity in training—are all strong arguments against using MMA training for other sports. Each sport has its own demands and its own training requirements. For success in your sport, follow its specific training program.

Photo:  xtremecouture.wordpress.com

Personal trainer and strength coach Joe Dowdell is one of the most highly sought after fitness experts in the world. His motivating teaching style and unique expertise have helped a clientele that includes film and TV stars, musicians, pro athletes, CEOs and top fashion models. Peak Performance, his 10,000-sq.-ft. loft in NYC, was voted the #3 gym in America by Men’s Health. Dowdell is a scientific advisory board member of Fitness Magazine; a regular contributor to Men’s Health, Women’s Health and Fitness Magazine; and an on-camera expert for both Men’s Health and HealthGuru.com. For more information, visit www.joedowdell.com or www.peakperformancenyc.com—or follow him on Twitter at www.twitter.com/joedowdellnyc.

Joe Dowdell
- Personal trainer and strength coach Joe Dowdell is one of the most highly sought after fitness experts in the world. His motivating teaching style and...
Joe Dowdell
- Personal trainer and strength coach Joe Dowdell is one of the most highly sought after fitness experts in the world. His motivating teaching style and...

Featured Videos

Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 2: Laying the Groundwork Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 2: Laying the Groundwork Views: 199,152
Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 4: Skill Training Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 4: Skill Training Views: 399,142
Path to the Pros 2015: Shaq Thompson Path to the Pros 2015: Shaq Thompson Views: 77,649
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill
Views: 6,866,321
Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied
Views: 12,224,126
Ohio State Football Open Field Plyo Drill Ohio State Football Open Field Plyo Drill
Views: 9,501,467
Dustin Pedroia on Training Dustin Pedroia on Training
Views: 10,921,007
Dwight Howard Stays in the Gym All Night Dwight Howard Stays in the Gym All Night
Views: 6,202,163

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like
2015 Summer Training Guide: Soccer

2015 Summer Training Guide: Soccer

2015 Summer Training Guide: Volleyball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Volleyball

Why You Should Add Depth Jumps to Your Workouts

Why You Should Add Depth Jumps to Your Workouts

2015 Summer Training Guide: Softball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Softball

A Modern Twist to the Original Burpee

A Modern Twist to the Original Burpee

Why Reverse Lunges Are Better Than Forward Lunges

Why Reverse Lunges Are Better Than Forward Lunges

Mix Up Your Workout With Unique Partner Exercises

Mix Up Your Workout With Unique Partner Exercises

How to Build Strong Neck Muscles

How to Build Strong Neck Muscles

Bulletproof Shoulders: A Shoulder Training Guide

Bulletproof Shoulders: A Shoulder Training Guide

9 Ways to Improve Your Squat Technique

9 Ways to Improve Your Squat Technique

2015 Summer Training Guide: Track

2015 Summer Training Guide: Track

Building Brakes for More Speed

Building Brakes for More Speed

2015 Summer Training Guide: Baseball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Baseball

Heavy Rope Workout for Big Gains

Heavy Rope Workout for Big Gains

There Might Be a Good Reason Tim Tebow Looks This Ridiculous

There Might Be a Good Reason Tim Tebow Looks This Ridiculous

2015 Summer Training Guide: Wrestling

2015 Summer Training Guide: Wrestling

The 10-Minute Grip Strengthening Workout

The 10-Minute Grip Strengthening Workout

10 Biceps Exercises Better Than Traditional Curls

10 Biceps Exercises Better Than Traditional Curls

Marcus Mariota's Speed and Strength Workout

Marcus Mariota's Speed and Strength Workout

2015 Summer Training Guide: Lacrosse

2015 Summer Training Guide: Lacrosse

Strength Isn’t Just How Much You Can Lift on a Barbell

Strength Isn't Just How Much You Can Lift on a Barbell

2015 Summer Training Guide: Basketball

2015 Summer Training Guide: Basketball

Why Single-Arm and Single-Leg Training is Better for Athletes

Why Single-Arm and Single-Leg Training is Better for Athletes

What Sport Coaches Need to Know About Strength and Conditioning

What Sport Coaches Need to Know About Strength and Conditioning

Troubleshooting the Lunge: How to Fix Your Form

Troubleshooting the Lunge: How to Fix Your Form

Use Single-Leg Strength to Enhance Soccer Performance

Use Single-Leg Strength to Enhance Soccer Performance

Build Powerful Muscles With Velocity-Based Training

Build Powerful Muscles With Velocity-Based Training

3 Simple Tips to Gain Muscle Mass

3 Simple Tips to Gain Muscle Mass

Build Lower-Body Power with This Squat Workout

Build Lower-Body Power with This Squat Workout

Are You Using the Right Weight for Every Exercise?

Are You Using the Right Weight for Every Exercise?

Perfect Planks: How to Make this Classic Exercise More Effective

Perfect Planks: How to Make this Classic Exercise More Effective

The Squat Variation That Torches Your Core

The Squat Variation That Torches Your Core

Full-Body Training: 4 Dumbbell Ring Training Exercises

Full-Body Training: 4 Dumbbell Ring Training Exercises

Go Against Traditional Workout Order for Bigger Gains

Go Against Traditional Workout Order for Bigger Gains

Build Big Trap Muscles for More Powerful Shoulders

Build Big Trap Muscles for More Powerful Shoulders

10-Minute Dynamic Warm-Up for Any Workout

10-Minute Dynamic Warm-Up for Any Workout

Build Elite Strength With This Training System

Build Elite Strength With This Training System

2015 Summer Training Guide: Football

2015 Summer Training Guide: Football

5 Things to Remember When You Wing Your Workout

5 Things to Remember When You Wing Your Workout

3 Bear Crawl Variations for Better Core Strength

3 Bear Crawl Variations for Better Core Strength

Building Functional Balance for Figure Skaters

Building Functional Balance for Figure Skaters

Fix 7 Common Problem Areas with Exercises From Todd Durkin

Fix 7 Common Problem Areas with Exercises From Todd Durkin

YardBarker