How Does Walking Compare to the Elliptical Machine?

April 17, 2014

Must See Training Videos

Using the elliptical machine and walking or running for exercise have several similarities. Both offer the cardiovascular benefits of raising your heart rate, increasing blood flow and delivering oxygen throughout your body. But although similar physiological responses occur with both exercises, the question remains, which is better for you?

A recent post by Gretchen Reynolds in The New York Times Wellness section cataloged some of the differences between “ellipticaling” and walking. The elliptical machine is less weight-bearing than either running or walking. According to a recent study published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, on average, 201 percent of your body weight strikes the ground with each step during outdoor jogging, 175 percent during treadmill jogging, and 112 percent during walking—compared to only 73 percent during elliptical training. If you suffer from knee problems or sore joints, the elliptical is likely to be your preferred option.

RELATED: Study: Will Cardio Ruin Your Strength Workout?

In terms of muscle activation, another study found glute and thigh engagement are greater during elliptical training than during walking (but less than other activities.) However, elliptical training may put greater stress on the low back due to the way the muscles fire.

The elliptical trainer seems to significantly reduce impact on the joints compared to running or walking, but it is commonly thought that high-impact weight-bearing exercises strengthen bone health, cell regeneration and density.

Ultimately, whether walking or ellipticalling is better depends on your fitness goals, your personal preferences and any injury issues you might have. If you maximize the time you spend during your workouts (e.g., by performing interval training, using increased resistance, or climbing higher inclines), the results will be comparable regardless of the manner you use to achieve them.

Read More:

Topics: NEWS
Maddy Lucier
- As an associate editor for STACK, Maddy creates lifestyle, social media, gear and nutrition content for our audience of athletes. She played volleyball and basketball...
Maddy Lucier
- As an associate editor for STACK, Maddy creates lifestyle, social media, gear and nutrition content for our audience of athletes. She played volleyball and basketball...
Must See
Roy Hibbert 540 lbs Deadlift
Views: 1,560,472
Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied
Views: 9,311,796
Margus Hunt Benches 385 Pounds for Five Reps
Views: 20,334,813

Featured Videos

A Day in the Life of NBA D-League Star Seth Curry Views: 68,298
Kevin Love's Cone Hop Basketball Shooting Drill Views: 6,362
Eastbay Path to the Pros Episode 2: Laying the Groundwork Views: 127,960
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Perfect Dwyane Wade's Signature Euro Step
Views: 1,308,654
What Ryan Hall Eats for Breakfast
Views: 795,225
STACK Fitness Weekly: How To Do a Muscle-Up
Views: 778,612
Greg Nixon's Hill Training Program
Views: 705,718
Roy Hibbert 540 lbs Deadlift
Views: 1,560,472

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like

Victor Cruz's Pool Workout with a ViPR

Why All Athletes Should Do Soft Tissue Work

3 Great Ways to Reduce Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness

4 Unnecessary Things That Only Overcomplicate Your Workouts

WATCH: Sergio Ramos's Trampoline Wall Touch

Fixing Common Weaknesses in Lacrosse Players

5 Boss Workouts From Olympic Snowboarder Hannah Teter

Home Gyms in the 1800s Were a Lot Like Today's TRX Trainer

Introducing the 2015 'All-Gaines NFL Combine Team'

WATCH: Darnell Dockett Manhandles 655-Pound Tire

WATCH: Usain Bolt's 2-in-1 Decline Sit-Up with Bench Press

Improve Your Lacrosse Power With These Exercises

5 Big Benefits of Yoga for Basketball Players

WATCH: Travis Kelce's Split-Squat Jump with Battling Ropes

WATCH: D.J. Williams' Endurance-Crushing Towel Plank Walk

WATCH: Shawne Merriman's 'Bus Driver' Shoulder Workout

WATCH: Torrey Smith and the Human Hammer Pull-Down

The 3 Best Posture Exercises That Build Strength

SURVIVING SEALFIT: How Not to Hurt Yourself (Like I Did)

WATCH: Vontae Davis's Half-Box Squat with Plate

Odell Beckham Jr. Shows Out on the Speed Ladder

Kevin Love

WATCH: A. J. Green and Justin Houston Pushing a Truck

Lacrosse Players: Get Stronger on the Field with 4 Exercises

Michael Bamiro's Big Breakthrough

SURVIVING SEALFIT: 3 Ways SEAL-Style Workouts Change Your Life

How to Train for a Triathlon Without Going Broke

WATCH: Giuseppe Rossi's 360-Degree Pilates Side Plank

How to Time Training Peaks to Be Your Best When It Matters Most

How to Find the Perfect Strength Coach or Personal Trainer

Why These 7 NFL Receivers Do Pilates

WATCH: Takeo Spikes Still Working On Getting a Bigger Neck

The Dangers of Heat Stress for Athletes

Ndamukong Suh's High School Highlights Not What You'd Expect

Workouts of the Top Players in the 2015 NBA Playoffs

WATCH: David Wilson's Acrobat Ab Workout