Shepherd's Pie Makeover: Comfort Food After a Hard, Rainy Practice

June 21, 2013 | Kait Fortunato

Must See Nutrition Videos

Editor's Note: From the fast food drive-thru and the take-out box to the backyard BBQ, STACK Expert Kait Fortunato is taking our favorite indulgences and turning them into healthy, everyday meals. Now you can eat what you love on a daily basis without compromising your performance or your health. These simple do-it-yourself recipes prove you can eat good fats, lean protein and whole grains but still have meals that taste great. This week, Kait shows you how to create a healthy Shepherd's pie. (See Part One in this series: Grill a Guiltless Burger: The Healthy Cheeseburger Recipe.)

Shepherd's Pie

Seriously, what could be better after a rainy night practice than a pile of juicy beef covered with creamy mashed potatoes and cheese? (Hard day on the field? See Foods To Boost Your Mood After Tough Games.)

Shepherd's Pie practically screams comfort food. Unfortunately, the original recipe calls for items like cream cheese and butter, which are high in saturated fat (i.e., the unhealthy fat) and will not adequately fuel your performance.

Traditional Shepherd's Pie

  • 452 calories
  • 17 grams fat
  • 7 grams saturated fat
  • 295 mg sodium
  • 52 grams carbohydrates
  • 7 grams fiber

At first glance, this doesn't look too bad in terms of calories and fat for the occasional indulgence. But the calories come from saturated fat and unhealthy carbohydrates, which will leave you feeling heavy and slow.

Healthy Shepherd's Pie (adapted from this recipe)

With heavy casseroles, you're confined to small servings, but meals like this give you more bang for your buck.

For healthy shepherd's pie, we removed the creamed potatoes due to their high glycemic index and need for butter. This eliminated some of the saturated fat. Thanks to great seasonings and a variety of add-ins, we were also able to sneak in more servings of vegetables. This swap provides healthier carbohydrates to replenish your energy levels after practice or a game. (Want more great seasonings? Check out The Powerful Health Benefits of Turmeric.)

To keep the same creamy texture as the original recipe, I recommend a side of baked sweet or russet potato. This will allow you to control the amount of butter you consume.

Ingredients (serves 4):

  • 1 pound ground turkey
  • 1 medium onion
  • 2 cloves garlic
  • 2 large carrots
  • 1/2 cup mushrooms
  • 1/2 cup roasted corn (I love the Trader Joe's brand)
  • 1 tablespoon whole wheat flour
  • 1 head cauliflower, chopped
  • 1 egg
  • 1 tablespoon each of rosemary, thyme and sage

Directions

  • Preheat the oven to 400F
  • Boil the cauliflower in a pot over medium heat until soft (about seven to 10 minutes)
  • As the cauliflower boils, sautee the ground turkey until brown (about 10 to 15 minutes)
  • Chop vegetables and add to the cooked ground turkey; heat through until soft
  • Sprinkle in a tablespoon of flour and bring to a boil (because the turkey is so lean, there should be enough water in the pan)
  • Add half the seasonings
  • Drain the cauliflower and "mash" in one egg and the emaining seasoning (either by hand or with a blender)
  • Grease a nine-inch square pan and fill with the ground turkey and vegetable mixture
  • Top it off with the cauliflower mash and cook for 10 minutes at 400F
  • Switch the oven to broil so the top browns and cook for another 10 minutes

Nutritional Profile

  • 220 calories
  • 9 grams fat
  • 16 grams carbohydrates
  • 4 grams fiber
  • 26 grams protein
Kait Fortunato
- Kait Fortunato is a registered dietitian at Rebecca Bitzer & Associates, a large and experienced nutrition practice in Maryland. She focuses on individualized nutritional recommendations...
Kait Fortunato
- Kait Fortunato is a registered dietitian at Rebecca Bitzer & Associates, a large and experienced nutrition practice in Maryland. She focuses on individualized nutritional recommendations...

Featured Videos

Tim Tebow's NFL Off-Season Workout Tim Tebow's NFL Off-Season Workout Views: 153,019
Path to the Pros 2015: Trae Waynes Path to the Pros 2015: Trae Waynes Views: 80,502
Path to the Pros 2015: Marcus Mariota Path to the Pros 2015: Marcus Mariota Views: 1,270,518
Load More

Resources

STACK Fitness

Everything you need to be fitter than ever

STACK Conditioning

Sport-specific conditioning programs

Coaches and Trainers

Tips and advice for coaches and trainers

Magazine

Latest issues of STACK Magazine

STACK 4W

Women's sports workout, nutrition and lifestyle advice

Gamer

Gaming, entertainment and tech news

Basic Training

Military-style training for athletes

News

Find the latest news relevant to athletes

Most Popular Videos

Peyton Manning Dumbbell Bench With 80+ Pounds Peyton Manning Dumbbell Bench With 80+ Pounds
Views: 43,626,320
Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied Drew Brees Will Not Be Denied
Views: 12,170,372
Colin Kaepernick's Core Workout Colin Kaepernick's Core Workout
Views: 896,683
Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill Robert Griffin III Pocket Presence QB Drill
Views: 6,866,292
Ohio State Football Open Field Plyo Drill Ohio State Football Open Field Plyo Drill
Views: 9,501,395

Load More
More Cool Stuff You'll Like
5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Ground Turkey

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Ground Turkey

5 Healthy Recipes to Start Your New Year

5 Healthy Recipes to Start Your New Year

'Ultimate Oatmeal' Recipe For Runners

'Ultimate Oatmeal' Recipe For Runners

5 Healthy Stuffing Recipes for Turkey Day

5 Healthy Stuffing Recipes for Turkey Day

Kait's Meal of the Month: Healthy Chicken Piccata

Kait's Meal of the Month: Healthy Chicken Piccata

A Recipe for Healthy Turkey Burgers

A Recipe for Healthy Turkey Burgers

7 Delicious Muscle-Building Smoothie Recipes

7 Delicious Muscle-Building Smoothie Recipes

Recipe Makeover: Healthy Stuffed Mushrooms

Recipe Makeover: Healthy Stuffed Mushrooms

Kait's Meal of the Month: Eggplant Turkey Boats

Kait's Meal of the Month: Eggplant Turkey Boats

4 Easy Recipe Substitutions for Take-Out Food

4 Easy Recipe Substitutions for Take-Out Food

Delightful Desserts for the Grill

Delightful Desserts for the Grill

Fuel Your Next Run With This Homemade Energy Bar

Fuel Your Next Run With This Homemade Energy Bar

Simply Roasted Sweet Potato Recipes

Simply Roasted Sweet Potato Recipes

Healthy Snack Recipes for Hungry Athletes

Healthy Snack Recipes for Hungry Athletes

Quinoa Recipes: A Super-Healthy Grain, 5 Ways

Quinoa Recipes: A Super-Healthy Grain, 5 Ways

6 Delicious and Healthy Overnight Oatmeal Recipes

6 Delicious and Healthy Overnight Oatmeal Recipes

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Eggs

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Eggs

Fill the Energy Void With These 5 Healthy Snack Ideas

Fill the Energy Void With These 5 Healthy Snack Ideas

3 Power-Packed Milkshakes to Boost Recovery

3 Power-Packed Milkshakes to Boost Recovery

3 Summer Shakes That Boost Athletic Performance

3 Summer Shakes That Boost Athletic Performance

7 Easy-to-Make Recipes for Gluten-Free Snacks

7 Easy-to-Make Recipes for Gluten-Free Snacks

Start Your New Year With These Holiday-Inspired Smoothies

Start Your New Year With These Holiday-Inspired Smoothies

5 Non-Boring, Easy and Healthy Canned Tuna Recipes

5 Non-Boring, Easy and Healthy Canned Tuna Recipes

Easy Thanksgiving Leftover Meals

Easy Thanksgiving Leftover Meals

Protein-Packed Smoothies Without Protein Powder

Protein-Packed Smoothies Without Protein Powder

Weight Loss and the Mediterranean Style Diet

Weight Loss and the Mediterranean Style Diet

3 Holiday Recipes that Won't Ruin Healthy Habits

3 Holiday Recipes that Won't Ruin Healthy Habits

4 Post-Workout Shakes for Recovery and Building Muscle

4 Post-Workout Shakes for Recovery and Building Muscle

Make Gains With This Post-Workout Shake Recipe

Make Gains With This Post-Workout Shake Recipe

Paleo-Friendly Meals for CrossFit Athletes

Paleo-Friendly Meals for CrossFit Athletes

Rate My Breakfast Plate: How Top Trainers' Breakfasts Stack Up

Rate My Breakfast Plate: How Top Trainers' Breakfasts Stack Up

Cooking for the Cooking-Inept: The Slow Cooker, Explained

Cooking for the Cooking-Inept: The Slow Cooker, Explained

A Better Baked Ziti

A Better Baked Ziti

Lunch Box Special: Tobin Heath's Old-School Pre-Game Favorite

Lunch Box Special: Tobin Heath's Old-School Pre-Game Favorite

Gain or Lose Weight With Oatmeal Pancakes

Gain or Lose Weight With Oatmeal Pancakes

3 Protein-Packed Peanut Butter Recipes

3 Protein-Packed Peanut Butter Recipes

5 Quick and Easy 5-Ingredient Recipes

5 Quick and Easy 5-Ingredient Recipes

Mix It Up With These High-Protein Meatloaf Muffin Snacks

Mix It Up With These High-Protein Meatloaf Muffin Snacks

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Salmon

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Salmon

3 Recipes to Spice Up Chocolate Milk

3 Recipes to Spice Up Chocolate Milk

6 Ways to Liven Up Your Winter Diet With Citrus

6 Ways to Liven Up Your Winter Diet With Citrus

6 Simple Power Recipes for Vegetarian Athletes

6 Simple Power Recipes for Vegetarian Athletes

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Sweet Potatoes

5 Non-Boring Ways to Eat Sweet Potatoes

Cure Breakfast Boredom With 3 Simple Healthy 'Boosts'

Cure Breakfast Boredom With 3 Simple Healthy 'Boosts'

Kait's Meal of the Month: Crock Pot Beef Stew

Kait's Meal of the Month: Crock Pot Beef Stew

Kait's Meal of the Month: Roasted Spaghetti Squash

Kait's Meal of the Month: Roasted Spaghetti Squash

4 Athlete-Friendly Microwave Meals

4 Athlete-Friendly Microwave Meals

YardBarker